November 6, 2026 · Annie Grossman
What My Wedding Taught Me About Coercive Dog Training
My father’s threat didn’t change the guest list. It did change how I felt about seeing him there.
I got married nine years ago yesterday.
Here is my dog practicing being the ring bearer.

This is my parents at the wedding, walking down the aisle.

It was the last time I ever saw my father.
You’d think from his expressions that his daughter was marrying a Nigerian prince.
That’s because I was.
Joking! I was actually marrying a nice guy from New Jersey, the son of psychotherapists, the president of a nonprofit. He had an Ivy League PhD and spoke seven languages. But, more importantly, he was cute and we loved each other and were excited to become each other’s family.

November 5, 2017

Nine years and one day later!
We now have three kids and a cat and a dog in what is basically a one bedroom — but big for New York! We are very happy.
Did my parents doubt this union would last? Actually… I think they had a good feeling about it. I was pretty sure they liked my husband more than they liked me
So why did my dad look like he was an extra in the Poor Jud is Dead scene from a performance of Oklahoma! put on in The Villages?
Because coercion had reared its ugly head.
Some background: My father was a much beloved, highly talented and prolific political cartoonist in the 1970s— he was illustrating the covers of Rolling Stone and Time on the regular in that decade and had strip in New York Magazine. He met my mom because she was an agent for illustrators in NYC and he needed an agent: he and his wife and three kids were moving out of New York so he wanted to have boots on the ground getting him work in the big city.
The story was that she only ever got him one job, but they fell in love and got married— a much higher commmission situation, if you will.

A drawing my dad did of me and my dog, Amos, in 2007.
My dad had three children from his first marriage. Although they’d been separated for some time, he officially divorced his first wife the week before marrying my mom, and I was born three weeks later.
So. You know. I can imagine that was probably hard on the kids.

My parents, around the time I was born.
Fast forward a few decades.
Our wedding reception was a small brunch, a stone’s throw from our apartment. We paid for it ourselves. There were many people who did not get invited. Most, people, in fact, were not invited. Among the non-invited? My half siblings. I hadn’t spent a lot of time with them growing up and they were a lot of older than I was. As an adult, the bad interactions I had with them felt like they outweighed the good ones.
But everyone was very gracious about it. Not! Joke! Again!
Two of them told me I was a terrible person for excluding them. My father agreed.
He told me that if I didn’t invite all his children, he wouldn’t come.
I didn’t invite them. He came anyway.
But he gave me the silent treatment the whole time..
He died not long afterward. I never saw him again.
I think about this incident every year on my anniversary. I even talk about it n my book, which is about dog training. Why would I tell some sad family story about people who don’t get along in a book about dog training?
Because humans try to change other’s behavior all the time. When a human tries to change a dog’s behavior, it’s training. Obedience is the goal however you get there. Will you try to get there sometimes using reinforcement and sometimes using punishment? Yes.
Thing is, with humans, when we try to change each other’s behavior, we don’t often think about it as training. It’s just life. It’s Sustack essay fodder.
Threats Sort of Suck
My wedding is a pretty good illustration of something that gets lost when we talk about using threats to change behavior. It can really just suck for everyone.
My father’s threat didn’t work. I didn’t change the guest list.
But it did change something: how I felt about having him at my wedding.
This was a man I loved like crazy. We had a really good relationship. And yet, in that moment, I found myself not particularly wanting him there at all.
A lifetime of good feelings was suddenly overshadowed by one threat.
I don’t think he felt very good about it either. He’d backed himself into a corner. If he stayed home, he’d miss his daughter’s wedding. If he came, he’d be going back on his word.
Someone was going to lose. As it turned out, I think we both did.
I think about this when I threaten my kids with the loss of TV time if they don’t put on their pajamas.
I think about it when I see someone using leash pressure or training collars to get a dog to walk nicely.
Threats and aversive consequences can change behavior. Sometimes very effectively.
But behavior isn’t the only thing being changed.
Associations are being formed, too. About the person delivering the threat. About the situation. About what it feels like to be together.
My kids can’t necessarily articulate those associations. Neither can our dogs.
And often times instances of coercion don’t leave this kind of lasting impression.
But nine years into a loving, happy marriage, I still have mixed feelings about my wedding day.
And I wish I didn’t.
Originally published in my newsletter, Don't Be a Dick to Your Dog.