Free illustrated guide: How Not To Be A Dick To Your Dog Get it free →
Annie Grossman — Professional Dog Person

November 17, 2026 · Annie Grossman

Can a Five-Year-Old Teach You How to Train Your Dog?

Barking, bed-sharing, humping, and other pressing canine questions from the latest DOG TALK.

Hello, humans! And digital-native dogs.

Last week, my five-year-old daughter, Goldie, joined me for DOG TALK, my new weekly live Q&A about dogs, dog training, and the science of behavior. Goldie is a dog expert —as in, expert on the topic of a dog: Poppy.

Goldie with her big sisters. Maggie recently told me she is actually more of a cat person.

Goldie with her big sisters. Maggie recently told me she is actually more of a cat person.

Her kindergarten friends had submitted some questions for her to answer. And I figured, since she’s spent her entire life being raised by a dog trainer, she was probably qualified to field at least a few of them.

I was right!

Question: Why do dogs sniff pee?

Goldie: “Because that is how they make friends.”

When Poppy is taking an extra beat to sinff while we are on a walk in the neighborhood, I tell my kids that she needs a moment to check her “pee-mail.” It’s how she learns things about the other dogs in the area.

What’s funny is that my kids don’t actually know what checking email is. It’s going to be funny when they find out!

Question: Can you teach an old dog new tricks?

Goldie: “Yes!”

Correct! In fact, I sometimes think older dogs are easier to train than puppies. They’ve had more practice figuring out how the world works, even if no one has been teaching them conscientiously. I’ve seen older dogs who seem quite relieved when someone actually starts training them in a way that makes sense to them. It’s like the static tuned out. Finally, a damn human who speaks my language!

Question: My dog growled when I tried to hug her. Was she being mean?

Goldie: “No. She was just scared, and she didn’t know what she was doing to her.”

Then she clarified: “She isn’t bad, she was ‘Saying, give me some space!’”

Amen! A growl is communication, not a character flaw. And respecting a dog’s request for space is one of the most important things we can teach children (and adults!) about interacting with dogs.

Question: Is it okay to let your dog sleep in your bed?

Goldie: “Yes! Unless you don’t want your bed to get dirty…”

She then revealed that our dog sleeps in our beds and we “never ever” clean our sheets.

This is true — well, the dog-sleeping-in-the-bed part is true. Bed-sleeping is Poppy’s favorite thing. She has her own bed, but she prefers my bed. Specifically, she likes sleeping on top of me in my bed. This is also the preferred position of my three children. And the cat.

This is why I look so tired all the time.

Poppy and Sarah in their natural habitat.

Poppy and Sarah in their natural habitat.

On the topic of Poppy: Goldie also wanted to demonstrate the indoor jumping game I play with our dog, Poppy, to give her cardiovascular exercise when it’s yucky outside. This is where I put my leg up on the table and Poppy jumps over my legs.

Unfortunately, Poppy declined to participate, so my seven-year-old played the part of the dog. I did not get photo evidence of this, but it really happened.

Me, at home, parenting, drinking and dog training at at once. Housekeeping… not so much!

Me, at home, parenting, drinking and dog training at at once. Housekeeping… not so much!

We also had some excellent questions from the grown-ups.

One participant introduced us to Chief, a handsome rescue pit mix who has recently started barking at people approaching the house. We talked about why barking isn’t necessarily something we need to eliminate (we did, after all, spend many thousands of years encouraging dogs to alert us to intruders and now are like SFU… humans are fickle folk). We talked about how to teach an alternative version of this behavior that can keep an alert from turning into a full-blown barking marathon (See: Thank You For Barking Protocol).

Another participant asked why her female dog humps her when she’s happy.

My answer? I like to say that dogs are like fifth graders at a dance party. They only have so many moves! Humping isn’t necessarily sexual; sometimes it’s simply an outlet for excitement.1

Your golden retriever when he sees your laundry bag.

Your golden retriever when he sees your laundry bag.

We also talked about treats, weight management, walking two dogs at once in New York City, and whether dogs really love us or just love the things we provide for them.

One thing I love about these conversations is that there’s often no single right answer. Every dog, household, and human-dog relationship is different. Understanding the science of behavior gives us a framework for figuring out what might work, but it doesn’t mean every question has a neat, universal solution.

And sometimes a five-year-old can cut through all the jargon and get right to the point.

Join us for the next DOG TALK!

DOG TALK is my weekly live Q&A where you can ask me anything about dogs, training, behavior, and the mysteries of living with another species.

Bring your dog. Bring your questions. Bring your barking, humping, bed-hogging problems.

No dominance nonsense, no quick fixes, and no judgment. Just practical, science-based advice and some good conversation.

Sign up for the next DOG TALK here! Wedensday at noon ET!

Dog Talk is free for paid subscribers to Don’t Be a Dick to Your Dog. Not a paid subscriber? You can join an individual session for just $10.

Tomorrow (11/18) I will be reading from the prologue of How To Train Your Dog With Love + Science.

Children welcome. Expertise optional.

Footnotes

  1. If you really want to delve deep into my thoughts on humping… lucky you! I did a podcast episode on humping in 2020 and was recently interviewed on the topic by adoptatpet.com. ↩

Originally published in my newsletter, Don't Be a Dick to Your Dog.